dhanKit
Back to articles

Cumulative vs Non-Cumulative FD: Which is Better for You?

Understand the difference between cumulative and non-cumulative FDs. Learn which type suits your financial goals, tax implications, and when to choose each option.

When opening a Fixed Deposit, you'll face a choice: cumulative or non-cumulative. The interest rate is the same, but how you receive returns differs significantly.

The right choice depends on whether you need regular income or want maximum wealth creation.

The Core Difference

Feature Cumulative FD Non-Cumulative FD
Interest payout At maturity Monthly/Quarterly/Half-yearly/Yearly
Compounding Yes (interest on interest) No
Final amount Higher Lower
Regular income No Yes
Best for Wealth building Regular income needs

Calculate both options: Use our FD Calculator to compare returns.

How Each Type Works

Cumulative FD Example

₹10 Lakh for 5 years at 7%

Year Opening Balance Interest Earned Closing Balance
1 ₹10,00,000 ₹70,000 ₹10,70,000
2 ₹10,70,000 ₹74,900 ₹11,44,900
3 ₹11,44,900 ₹80,143 ₹12,25,043
4 ₹12,25,043 ₹85,753 ₹13,10,796
5 ₹13,10,796 ₹91,756 ₹14,02,552

Total interest earned: ₹4,02,552

Non-Cumulative FD Example (Quarterly Payout)

₹10 Lakh for 5 years at 7%

Year Quarterly Interest Annual Total Payout
Each quarter ₹17,500 ₹70,000 To bank account
5 years total - ₹3,50,000 Principal returned at end

Total interest earned: ₹3,50,000

The Compounding Difference

FD Type Total Interest (5 years) Difference
Cumulative ₹4,02,552 +₹52,552 more
Non-Cumulative ₹3,50,000 Baseline

Cumulative earns 15% more interest due to compounding.

When to Choose Cumulative FD

1. You Don't Need Regular Income

Your Situation Choose
Salaried with regular income Cumulative
Building wealth for future Cumulative
Saving for goal (5+ years away) Cumulative

2. Maximizing Returns is Priority

Investment Goal Cumulative Advantage
Child's education (10 years) ~28% more interest
Retirement corpus (15 years) ~45% more interest
Emergency fund growth Compounding helps

3. You're in Lower Tax Bracket

Tax Bracket TDS Impact Recommendation
0% (income < ₹7 L) File 15G/15H, no TDS Cumulative
5-10% Minimal impact Cumulative
20-30% Consider tax timing Either

4. You Want to Avoid Spending Temptation

Behavioral Factor Cumulative Benefit
Interest in bank account May get spent
Interest reinvested Forced saving

When to Choose Non-Cumulative FD

1. You Need Regular Income

Situation Payout Frequency
Retiree living on interest Monthly
Supplementing income Quarterly
Paying EMI/rent Monthly

2. You're a Senior Citizen

Benefit Details
Higher FD rates 0.25-0.75% extra
Regular pension-like income Monthly payout
Predictable cash flow Budget planning

3. Tax Planning Purposes

Strategy How Non-Cumulative Helps
Spread income across years Interest taxed each year
Avoid large lump sum tax No big maturity amount
Use basic exemption annually ₹40K interest exemption (senior citizens: ₹50K)

Detailed Comparison

Returns Comparison (₹10 L at 7%)

Tenure Cumulative Maturity Non-Cumulative Total Extra from Cumulative
1 year ₹10,70,000 ₹10,70,000 ₹0 (no difference)
3 years ₹12,25,043 ₹12,10,000 ₹15,043
5 years ₹14,02,552 ₹13,50,000 ₹52,552
7 years ₹16,05,781 ₹14,90,000 ₹1,15,781
10 years ₹19,67,151 ₹17,00,000 ₹2,67,151

Longer tenure = Greater compounding advantage.

Cash Flow Comparison

Aspect Cumulative Non-Cumulative
Year 1 income ₹0 ₹70,000
Year 2 income ₹0 ₹70,000
Year 3 income ₹0 ₹70,000
Year 4 income ₹0 ₹70,000
Year 5 income ₹0 ₹70,000
At maturity ₹14,02,552 ₹10,00,000
Total received ₹14,02,552 ₹13,50,000

Liquidity Comparison

Factor Cumulative Non-Cumulative
Regular access to interest No Yes
Break FD for emergency Penalty applies Can use interest first
Flexibility Lower Higher

Tax Implications

TDS Rules (Same for Both)

Condition TDS Rate
Interest > ₹40,000/year 10% TDS
Interest > ₹50,000 (seniors) 10% TDS
No PAN 20% TDS
Form 15G/15H submitted No TDS

Tax Timing Difference

FD Type When Tax Applies
Cumulative On accrued interest each year (even if not received)
Non-Cumulative On interest received each year

Important: Even cumulative FD interest is taxable annually on accrual basis, not at maturity.

Tax Planning Strategy

Non-Cumulative advantage for high-value FDs:

Scenario Cumulative Non-Cumulative
₹50 L FD, 7%, 5 years Year 5: ₹3.5 L interest taxable Yearly: ₹70K taxable
Tax at 30% ₹1.05 L (if assessed in one year) ₹21K/year

Spreading income may keep you in lower bracket.

Choosing Based on Life Stage

Young Professional (25-35 years)

Recommendation Reasoning
Cumulative Don't need regular income, maximize compounding
Tenure 3-5 years
Payout Not applicable

Middle-Aged (35-50 years)

Recommendation Reasoning
Cumulative (if stable income) Still building wealth
Non-Cumulative (if irregular income) Income smoothing

Pre-Retirement (50-60 years)

Recommendation Reasoning
Mix of both Start transitioning to income
Cumulative For goals 5+ years away
Non-Cumulative Practice for retirement income

Retired (60+ years)

Recommendation Reasoning
Non-Cumulative Need regular income
Payout frequency Monthly for expenses
Consider Senior citizen special FDs

Payout Frequency Options (Non-Cumulative)

Frequency Interest Calculation Effective Rate*
Monthly Simple interest ~6.96%
Quarterly Quarterly compounding ~7.00%
Half-yearly Semi-annual compounding ~7.12%
Yearly Annual compounding ~7.00%

*For 7% stated rate

Note: Less frequent payouts = slightly higher effective rate.

Monthly vs Quarterly Decision

Choose Monthly If Choose Quarterly If
Need income for expenses Can manage with less frequency
Prefer regular deposits Want slightly higher effective rate
Budgeting monthly Have other income sources

Hybrid Strategy: Best of Both Worlds

FD Ladder with Mixed Types

FD Amount Type Purpose
FD 1 ₹3 L Non-Cumulative (Monthly) Monthly income
FD 2 ₹2 L Cumulative Emergency reserve growth
FD 3 ₹3 L Cumulative Medium-term goal
FD 4 ₹2 L Cumulative Long-term growth

Benefits:

  • Regular income from FD 1
  • Compounding growth from FDs 2-4
  • Staggered maturities reduce reinvestment risk

Income + Growth Strategy

For Retiree with ₹50 L
₹30 L Non-Cumulative ₹17,500/month income
₹20 L Cumulative Grows for future needs

Real-World Scenarios

Scenario 1: Building Emergency Fund

Goal: ₹6 L emergency fund from ₹5 L

Choice Result
Cumulative 3-year FD at 7% ₹6.13 L (goal achieved)
Non-Cumulative ₹5 L + ₹1.05 L interest (spent?)

Verdict: Cumulative ensures goal is met.

Scenario 2: Retiree Needing Income

Corpus: ₹40 L | Need: ₹20,000/month

FD Type Amount Monthly Income
Non-Cumulative at 7.5% ₹32 L ₹20,000
Remaining Cumulative ₹8 L Growth for inflation

Verdict: Non-cumulative for income need.

Scenario 3: Tax-Saving FD

5-year tax-saving FD (80C benefit)

Type Consideration
Cumulative Most FDs are cumulative only
Non-Cumulative Few banks offer this option

Note: Most tax-saving FDs are cumulative by default.

Quick Decision Guide

Your Situation Choose Reason
Working, stable income Cumulative Maximize returns
Retired, need regular income Non-Cumulative Monthly cash flow
Building goal-based corpus Cumulative Compounding benefit
Supplementing irregular income Non-Cumulative Income smoothing
Short tenure (< 2 years) Either Minimal difference
Long tenure (5+ years) Cumulative Significant compounding
Tax planning needed Non-Cumulative Spread income
Avoid spending temptation Cumulative Money stays invested

Conclusion

Factor Winner
Higher returns Cumulative
Regular income Non-Cumulative
Long-term goals Cumulative
Retirement income Non-Cumulative
Simplicity Either
Tax spreading Non-Cumulative

Bottom line:

  • Choose Cumulative if you don't need regular income and want maximum returns
  • Choose Non-Cumulative if you need regular cash flow (retirees, income supplementation)
  • Use both for a balanced approach that provides income while growing wealth

The decision isn't about which is "better"—it's about which fits your financial needs.


Compare both options: Use our FD Calculator to see returns for cumulative and non-cumulative FDs.

Try These Calculators